Revealed on
The US authorities sued California over its regulation of eggs and chickens, claiming that “pointless pink tape” provoked an egg value spike throughout the nation.
“The legal guidelines and rules challenged by the grievance impose pricey necessities on farmers which have the impact of elevating egg costs for American customers by prohibiting farmers throughout the nation from utilizing generally accepted agricultural strategies that helped preserve eggs reasonably priced,” mentioned a press release from the Division of Justice.
The lawsuit, filed in Los Angeles, focused three items of laws: AB 1437, Proposition 2 and Proposition 12.
It argued that nationwide egg regulation is the accountability of the federal authorities, quite than states, to permit for “nationwide uniformity”. California can regulate farms throughout the state, however it can’t impose necessities on eggs from different states which might be bought in California, mentioned the lawsuit.
The disputed legal guidelines impose plenty of necessities associated to meals security and animal welfare. For instance, Proposition 2 prevents farmers from confining a rooster to the extent the place it’s unable to “lie down, arise, totally prolong its limbs, and switch round freely”.
This isn’t the primary time that California’s egg rules have sparked authorized challenges. Six states sued California in 2014, though the plaintiffs misplaced the case in each a federal district courtroom and a courtroom of appeals.
In March this 12 months, the US Division of Justice additionally launched an investigation to find out whether or not egg producers had been value fixing throughout the chook flu outbreak.
Main producer Cal-Maine Meals, probed by the DOJ, reported internet earnings of $508.5mn for the December to February quarter, a 247% year-on-year improve.
In 2024, egg costs rose 65%, though they began to fall once more in April this 12 months.
Earlier this 12 months, Turkey agreed to ship 5,000 tonnes of eggs to the US by July to assist alleviate the scarcity.