Mercury in flu vaccines. Credit score: Inside Artistic Home, Shutterstock
A key US well being panel has voted to part out Thimerosal, a mercury-based preservative utilized in some seasonal flu vaccines.
The vote got here on June 27, 2025, throughout a gathering of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), a gaggle that guides nationwide vaccine suggestions for the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention (CDC). The committee beneficial that each one kids and adults ought to solely obtain single-dose flu vaccines that don’t comprise thimerosal.
What’s Thimerosal and why is it controversial?
Thimerosal (additionally spelled thiomersal) is an ethylmercury-based preservative used because the Nineteen Thirties to forestall bacterial and fungal development in multi-dose vaccines. Based on the CDC, it has a robust security document.
Whereas most childhood vaccines within the US have been thimerosal-free since 2001, the ingredient stays in some multi-dose flu vaccines, which make up about 5 per cent of whole doses.
Regardless of its many years of use and repeated research displaying no dangerous results, thimerosal has lengthy been a goal of anti-vaccine advocates, lots of whom hyperlink it to neurological hurt and autism.
The ACIP’s newest vote was 5 in favour of eliminating thimerosal, one towards, and one abstention. So why is there a need to eradicate it?
The panel was not too long ago reshaped by US Well being Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr, a long-time vaccine critic. Kennedy fired all 17 former members in early June and changed them with eight new members.
Critics declare the panel’s agenda was influenced by anti-vaccine speech. A scheduled CDC presentation reviewing the scientific proof supporting thimerosal’s security was supposedly scrapped, and as a substitute, a presentation was delivered by Lyn Redwood, a nurse and founding father of the World Mercury Mission, a precursor to Kennedy’s Kids’s Well being Protection. Her presentation reportedly included at the least one unverified examine.
Responding to issues, panel chair Dr Martin Kulldorff – a former Harvard professor sacked for refusing the Covid-19 vaccine – mentioned, “It’s inappropriate to dismiss a presentation simply because the individual doesn’t have a PhD or MD” (Cited by The Guardian).
Dr Cody Meissner, the lone ‘no’ vote and professor of paediatrics at Dartmouth’s Geisel Faculty of Drugs, warned that eliminating thimerosal may restrict entry to flu vaccines globally.
“The chance from influenza is a lot larger than the nonexistent – so far as we all know – danger from thimerosal,” Meissner mentioned. “I’d hate for an individual to not obtain the influenza vaccine as a result of the one accessible preparation comprises thimerosal.” (The Guardian.)
World implications of phasing out thimerosal in flu vaccines
Though the ACIP’s suggestions solely instantly have an effect on the US, they’re typically adopted globally, notably in lower-income international locations the place multi-dose vials are crucial as a result of value and storage constraints.
Thimerosal permits producers to package deal flu vaccines in vials that serve a number of sufferers, chopping prices and logistical burdens. With out it, international locations is likely to be compelled to modify to single-dose formulations, that are costlier and more durable to distribute.
Dr Jacob Glanville, CEO of Centivax, a San Francisco biotech firm, famous, “We help any effort to take away it fully – there are different preservatives that aren’t primarily based on mercury” (Cited by Fox Information).
View all well being information.