‘Two Times João Liberada’ review: Portuguese LGBTQ+ title is a niche debut

Dir: Paula Tomás Marques. Portugal. 2025. 70mins

A venture that walks the road between biographical drama and conceptual artwork piece, the experimental Portuguese LGBTQ+ ventureTwo Instances João Liberada challenges the conventions of the biopic and takes on the patriarchal constructions that also maintain sway over a lot of cinematic storytelling. It’s concerning the making of a misguided movie a few fictional historic character, João Liberada, a gender non-conforming shepherdess who was focused and imprisoned by the Inquisition in 18th century Portugal, and is prone to be of area of interest attraction.

Challenges the conventions of the biopic

The venture is the function debut from Paula Tomás Marques, who has made a number of quick movies exploring gender and sexuality, together with 2019’s In Case Of Fireplace, which gained Finest Pupil Quick at San Sebastian, and 2024’s Dildotectónica. Two Instances João Liberada is a movie that was clearly made on a restricted finances, and the ambition of a venture that includes interval particulars, particular results and a supernatural visitation needs to be applauded. That stated, the image’s modest manufacturing values and unpolished performances will probably restrict its attain to audiences who share the movie’s prominently displayed politics.

Marques shares the writing duties on the venture with June João, the transfemme actress who stars within the movie and gives a narration. João, whose character within the movie shares the identical title, explains that she accepted the position within the movie about Liberada regardless of grave reservations concerning the venture’s method and, particularly, the movie’s director Diogo (André Tecedeiro). It’s a little bit of a thankless position for Tecedeiro, who’s principally the autumn man and punching bag, representing the evils of cis male entitlement and ignorance.

João finds herself more and more at odds with Diogo over the route that the movie is taking. And rightly so – for his overuse of hackneyed music selections alone, Diogo deserves a stint in director jail. However João’s predominant problem is that the movie is preoccupied with the tragedy of its topic, dwelling on a soggily-staged suicide sequence. João’s argument is that there’s as a lot to rejoice in Liberada’s radical life as there’s to grieve within the method of its ending. And the ghost of João Liberada, moderately shonkily added to a number of nighttime scenes, apparently agrees along with her. The voice of the ghost, distorted and accompanied by glitchy visible interference, speaks to João, waking her from her sleep (“Lady, wake the fuck up!”) to bitch concerning the venture (“Schubert? Actually?”).

The argument the image makes is that any historic biographical illustration is basically untrustworthy as a result of it’s considered by means of the lens of the creator telling the story. Within the case of Diogo the director, meaning dwelling on the tortured, tragic societal reject facet of the character. It’s a good level. However giving Liberada a voice that speaks in fashionable idioms and chimes with fashionable political sensibilities is arguably simply as a lot of a perversion.